Showing posts with label LO#2A. Show all posts
Showing posts with label LO#2A. Show all posts

Monday, April 11, 2011

Aesthetic Cohesion, Transliteration, and Morality in Historia Danica, "Hamlet," and "Rosencrantz and Guildenstern"

This post is a continuation of my emphasis on Renaissance Teaching Methods.  It is also a follow up post to previous research that I mentioned performing in regards to a relationship between Hisotria Danica, “Hamlet,” and “Rosencrantz and Guildenstern are Dead.”  I will be discussing how transliteration affected the depiction of morality in the portrayal of several more explicit scenes.  Let me begin by explaining a bit about transliteration.

Sunday, April 3, 2011

Renaissance Learning: My Personal Findings

This course has been challenging and rewarding at the same time.  The learning curve was substantially high at the beginning of the course, yet rather than being daunting, I feel that the experience has inspired me.  This post is a summation of my observations about the academic blog, and my emphasis on Renaissance Teaching Methods.  I have built a personal learning plan that reached the following working thesis.  I call it working because while it does make a specific claim, that claim is mostly based on my learning process thus far, and given additional time, would likely further adjust becoming even more specific.  Here is that thesis:

Returning to the Renaissance Teaching Methods employed to teach English, particularly the practice of the Imitation of subject and form, will help students develop a system of analysis that they can apply to texts in visual, audio, tactile, and written formats.

Let me explain how I got here:

Tuesday, March 29, 2011

Rhetorical Exercise-Imitation

In this post I will be engaging in a few Rhetorical Exercises to demonstrate what I have learned thus far in my study of the Renaissance Teaching Method.  I will be following the four categories of change defined in Dr. Burtons summary.  While engaging in these practice segments has been a part of my plan for some time now, I was reading in Brooke K’s recent blog regarding the art of Imitation and felt a greater desire to engage the subject directly.  I will be demonstrating the art of Imitation in the two forms described in my post Critical Definitions 2.  I will be basing my derivatives From Shakespeare’s Sonnet 18:

Sunday, February 27, 2011

Adjusting the Connotations


For class we are reviewing a segment of the play Julius Caesar.  We need to review the section according to a specific Literary Theory.  We are reviewing Act 3 Scene 2.  In this scene Brutus has killed Caesar and is explaining to the Plebeian's his reasons, at the finishing of his remarks Antony arrives with the body of Caesar and gives an address.  Since i have been focusing on Rhetorical strategies of the plays in my blog I wanted utilize a literary theory that would add to this focus.  I decided to do a Structuralist reading of this scene, specifically focusing on the True Symbol defined by Saussure...

Friday, February 25, 2011

Searching for a Source

I enjoyed a bit of serendipity when searching for a scholarly source for today.  I visited the library and hunted down the Shakespeare section.  I wanted to unearth a book focused particularly on rhetorical strategies in Shakespeare.  So, I went personally to the section of Shakespeare research and I found a book titled “Why Shakespeare” by Gerald M. Picniss.  Provided my focus on the idea of compartmentalizing the tools of Shakespeare’s success, I was intrigued by the title of this work.  It did not disappoint.  I was able to review some brief segments of the book, and look forward to utilizing it more fully.  The book attempts to explain the specific strategies incorporated in Shakespeare’s plays that make them successful.  He analyses the structure of the plays in the first half of the book, while the latter half hone in on the various Rhetorical strategies of the plays.  For instance chapter six deals exclusively with the mixing of Verse and Prose in the plays and how this mixture engages the viewer mentally through its development of wit.  This chapter specifically will help me in my rhetorical analysis of the plays, which I am very excited about since I am attempting to imitate much of this in the play that I am crafting.

Monday, February 14, 2011

Culture as a Weapon?


Honestly, I had no idea what a “Moor” was and had to look it up while I was reading the play.  In the article “’That which Heaven Hath Forbid the Ottomites’: The Turks in Shakespeare’s Othello” by Joseph Locket he explains “Othello is a Moor, one of the North Africans remaining in Spain after the overthrow of the Islamic governments there.”  Luckily, in our class discussion last Friday my group really dug into Othello, particularly in the aspect of the importance of race.  We all agreed that perhaps the issue of race was one of the strong points of Othello that makes the play so distinct from many of the other main tragedies.  For instance, the rage expressed my Desdemona’s Father would seem like the same old paternal anger seen in a Shakespeare tragedy where it not for his prejudice towards Othello because he is the Moor.  Furthermore, I thought it was interesting that Othello was THE Moor, not just a moor of Venice.  Shakespeare goes through a good deal of trouble within the play to make this distinction a strong apparatus for comprehending the play with much more that simply defining Othello by his title. 

This focus on language was a key thing I notices when reading the play.  Compared to his other plays the diction of Othello seemed to contain a great deal of sophistication.  For instance, the enraged Duke berates Othello saying “the bloody book of law / you shall yourself read in the bitter letter / after your own sense – yea, though our proper son / stood in your action.”  I know Shakespeare is known for inverting sentence structure by repositioning verbs, and sometimes he sounds a bit like Yoda, (or I guess I should say Yoda sounds like Shakespeare) but the point is this play in particular seems replete with Sonnet-like lines.  This is significant in my opinion because it suggests to me that he is hiding something in the language of the play itself.  I have to admit that at first I really didn’t catch as many of these references as I have in review, but after reading Locket’s paper I think I was really on to something.  His paper is great if you want a good starting point for reading this play in light of the racial issues it brings to the surface.  I think reading it in this light both interesting, and timely given the conflict between the “western world” and the “eastern world” in contemporary society.  Clearly from the lines of Othello we see that this contention is ages old.

Tuesday, February 8, 2011

Dying for a Soliloquy

I think I have been spoiled.  I really enjoyed the Soul bearing soliloquies in Hamlet and Richard the III and found myself earnestly craving a peak into the mind of Iago.  He certainly steals the stage through the first 2 acts, but when I drew close to the end of the first act my hopes were diminishing.  To my great exultation, just as the 1st act reached its end all other characters walked off the stage and Iago began to bear his soul!  I wanted to jump up and down with fiendish laughter! (I guess that was my way of preparing to enter the mind of the madman)

When I thought about why I wanted to read a Soliloquy so much I remembered my earlier post about self-reflective characters and how they are more easily accessible.  This in turn lead me to review Iago’s dialogue up to that point to see what was making his character so complicated that I yearned for easier access.  I discovered that he employs several striking maxims that at once draw my attention, and obscure my understanding.  For instance:

-          “We cannot all be masters, nor all masters
Cannot be truly followed.”
-          “I am not what I am.”
-          “If the beam of our lives had not
One scale of reason to poise another of sensuality, the
Blood and baseness of our natures would conduct us
To most preposterous conclusions.”

These awesome lines were some of my favorites up to this point.  I think that I enjoy them so much because they contain many characteristics similar to those found in Shakespeare’s Sonnets.  For instance compare the two phrases:

-          “We cannot all be masters, nor all masters cannot be truly followed” – Iago
-          “My glass shall not persuade me I am old
So long as youth and thou are of one date” – Sonnet 22

Both sections attempt to define abstract ideas through concrete examples.  Both contain an argument, and a rebuttal.  I am certain that there are many more similarities that can be drawn, but the singularity of this mode of expression really drew me in.  As I continue to review the plays I’ll make certain to investigate this bleeding over of Sonnet form within the play. 

Wednesday, January 26, 2011

Cross Characterization

As I am reading through “Richard the III” I can’t help but notice a simple connection in characterization that exists between this play and “Hamlet.”  Throughout the later the audience is fascinated by the psychological depth of Hamlet.  For example, in act 2 scene 2 he curses:

“Oh, what a rogue and peasant slave am I!...
  I a dull and muddy-mettled rascal, peak
  Like John-a-dreams, unpregnant of my cause,
  And can say nothing – no, not for a king
  Upon whose property and most dear life
  A damned defeat was made.  Am I a coward?”

Similarly, in “Richard the III” the audience is at once repulsed, and allured by the king-to-be.  Look at his opening soliloquy:

           “Cheated of feature by dissembling Nature,
 Deformed, unfinished, sent before my time
 Into this breathing world scarce half made up,
And that so lamely and unfashionable
That dogs bark at me as I halt by them-…
And therefore, since I cannot prove a lover
            To entertain these fair well-spoken days,
            I am determined to prove a villain
            And hate the idle pleasures of these days.”

There is a similarity among these self aware characters that makes them more accessible to the audience.  While a given individual might not correlate with the death-plotting of these characters, by making them self aware the audience is able to relate to their sense of brooding, their questioning nature that muses over the finite principles of life.  These two of Shakespeare’s psychological characters in this way attach themselves to the dark side of human nature in the audience, which even if detested, or overcome through saintly living, is still recognizable in some degree in the audience.  What other similarities I will find by cross analyzing the plays?  This is fun!

Sunday, January 23, 2011

Acta non Verba

I started this post with the Latin phrase that means “Action not Words.”  I chose this title because of what I discovered on my recent exploits.  Today I drove back to Provo Utah from a nearly week-long excursion to see my best friend get married.  On the trip back, being heavily loaded with work to do, I made my friend drive for half the trip and read almost the entire first act of The Tragedy of King Richard the III.  She is not much of a rhetorician so it was interesting to see how she reacted to hearing old English.  I didn’t bother to attempt to explain the meaning behind obscure words, rather the more I noticed that she was not paying attention the more animated I became.  It was interesting to see the play really ‘come to life’ this way, and draws my attention to the reasoning behind WHY Shakespeare needs to be viewed or heard to be best understood.  The rhetorical structure of the play lends itself to the public audience more easily than to the private audience by virtue of its climax/resolution structure.  The scene for instance presents a problem and then begins the process of complicating the problem, or resolving it, but almost without fail the movement in Shakespeare’s plays is forward.  If you look at this play in particular, Richards’ dark plans grow more heinous as the scene progresses and the ebb and flow of the conversation among the characters peaks around the same moment of potential plot growth. This is a fascinating observation that I intend to explore further as I review the remainder of the play this week and as I move on to other plays in the weeks to follow.

Thursday, January 13, 2011

A posse ad esse

I started this post with a Latin Phrase that roughly translated means “from possibility to actuality.”  I still think of Latin as a power Language, and at the least intriguing, but this particular phrase encompasses the dilemma that I will address.  In my last post I posed questions about the plagiarisms of Shakespeare.  In my class we began discussing that, and my professor pointed out that while Shakespeare did clearly take many of his ideas from other works, many of the ideas were taken from works written in other languages.  As a by-product of his Renaissance education Shakespeare was skilled at analyzing which specific aspects of a work, even when in a language like Latin, made the work into a success.  Honestly, I covet this ability and think that it ought to be the focus of modern English education much more often than it is, but I digress.  Shakespeare utilized this model to heist the concepts he found most effective and to re-imagine them in his own way; in this way Shakespeare took a possibility and molded it into actuality.  For instance, the story of Hamlet closely follows that of Saxo Grammaticus’s Hisotria Danica, yet in my review of it I noticed that where Saxo’s work turned graphic, Shakespeare erred on the side of caution.

Finding out the protagonists intentions:
Hamlet = Ophelia                                 Danica = a Harlot
Killing Polonius:
Hamlet = stabbed                                 Danica = cut into pieces and dropped in the sewer
The End:
Hamlet = a duel and poison                  Danica = a Holocaust, and a vengeful second wife

The more tempered approach utilized by Shakespeare has had a longer lasting appeal, which really does say volumes about the limitations of creative expression.  Returning to my focus, while core features of the stories are the same, or similar, the interpretation of the events is different.  Interestingly, in looking up the definition of plagiarism the Encyclopedia Britannica defined it thus:
     The act of taking the writings of another person and passing them off as one’s own.
But also contained an intriguing closing comment that stated:
     If only thoughts are duplicated, expressed in different words, there is no breach of contract.

So, in this context is Shakespeare really a plagiarist? Or was he simply a really good reader, both of texts and audiences?